Fundrise vs Realty Mogul
As investors, we are always looking for ways to grow and diversify our portfolios. Whether we buy many different stocks or spread our money across different asset classes, diversification is key to a balanced portfolio. One key component of a well-rounded portfolio is real estate.
The problem is, real estate isn’t always the most passive investment. It can take a lot of hard work and time to maintain and manage a real estate investment. Also, the upfront investment is often quite high. If you are buying a rental property, get ready to shell out 20 to 25% of the value of the property as a down payment!
Recently, a number of different crowdfunded real estate investing platforms have emerged. This provides investors with a great way to passively invest in real estate all over the US! Instead of investing tens of thousands of dollars into a rental property, you can passively invest with a much smaller amount of money.
Many of these platforms offer unique features to investors, making it difficult to choose between them. In this post, we will compare two of the most popular crowdfunded real estate platforms; Fundrise versus Realty Mogul.
Realty Mogul vs Fundrise: Summary
- Fundrise has a lower minimum balance of $500 compared to $5,000 to invest with Realty Mogul.
- Realty Mogul only has two portfolios for non-accredited investors which are the Mogul REIT I and Mogul REIT II.
- Fundrise has four different portfolios available to all investors. The starter portfolio has a minimum balance of $500 while the advanced plans have a minimum of $1,000.
- Fees vary with Realty Mogul while Fundrise has a 1% management fee.
- Realty Mogul offers 1031 Exchanges and Private Placements for accredited investors.
- Distributions are paid monthly with Realty Mogul (REIT I) and quarterly with Fundrise.
- Investors should have a minimum 5 year commitment for either platform.
Traditional Real Estate Investing vs Crowdfunded
Another major roadblock to buying into real estate deals is the many demands on your time, energy and even your wallet.
Once you buy that coveted property, you become the landlord, shouldering all the responsibilities for upkeep, maintenance and longer-term repairs.
Maybe you can’t afford to buy that fixer-upper in upstate New York, or that condo in Chicago. But we’re here to tell you there’s a way to buy into property as a bonafide part owner that doesn’t require you to find tenants, collect rent, take care of lawn maintenance, or deal with leaky sinks.
Now there’s a viable way to buy into real estate projects that leaves you in a hands-off position. Experts will manage the property for you, including collecting rent and doling out your share. This phenomenon is called crowdfunding, where investors pool their money together to purchase real estate investments.
Crowdfunding offers a way for investors to earn passive income. This type of investment does not require experience, large amounts of capital, or connections like traditional real estate investing.
This means that after your initial investment, you just sit back and let the work get done and hopefully your investment grows in value. Investors may want to consider reinvesting their dividends to take advantage of compounding your investment.
Crowdsourcing is an alternative way to pool money to fund a project or venture by raising small amounts of money from a large number of people, typically via social media platforms. Crowdsourcing worldwide raises millions of dollars each year, with the platform continuing to pick up speed as more people opt-in.
Similar to real estate investment trusts or partnerships, all the investors pool their money together to purchase real estate. This is a combination of debt and equity deals, giving investors both growth and income potential.
Fundrise has changed the game by offering their starter portfolio with a $500 minimum balance. You can upgrade to one of their advanced plans at any time.
In a nutshell, Fundrise curates private real estate deals. With some of these deals, you are an owner who has equity in the property. In others, you serve as the bank having a debt interest.
Generally speaking, equity investments are growth investments, as you can capitalize on asset appreciation. Debt investments are income investments, as you aim to receive interest payments from the loan. Each portfolio holds a blend of both debt and equity investments.
How Much Should You Invest?
The average Fundrise investors are in their 30s, and while the median initial investment is $4,500, you can open a starter portfolio for just $500. This allows you to dip your toes in without going all in. At any time, you can upgrade from the starter portfolio to one of the advanced plans.
The amount that you invest is completely up to you, and how comfortable you feel about investing in crowdfunded real estate. Be cautious of over-allocating too much of your portfolio to any single position. Diversification is the key to managing your risk.
Real estate gurus also emphasize this isn’t a get-rich-quick avenue. It’s meant to be a long-term investment. If you have a minimum time horizon of approximately five years to put into the deal, Fundrise may be for you.
How Does Fundrise Work?
Fundrise aims to acquire assets with a high potential to grow in value.
The key here is to buy ahead of major demographic or cultural shifts, understand emerging neighborhood growth, or recognize untapped property potential. That’s where the experts come in.
Another focus is making major improvements to the property to increase the sale price.
Fundrise puts your investment to work on across-the-board improvements, like building new urban housing, renovating run-down apartments and renting out viable vacant buildings.
When the refurbished properties are sold, ideally, returns are recognized. There is far greater demand for complete real estate developments. Most people do not want to purchase a fixer upper.
What they have found is that there are many more potential homebuyers for a fully renovated home than a rundown fixer upper, and more renters for new luxury apartments near a metro area than for the previously vacant land.
How To Make Money With Fundrise
The two primary ways to make money with Fundrise are asset appreciation and income from rents or interest.
In debt investments, you and other investors act as the bank. The interest payments earned on the loan are paid out to you as quarterly dividends
The same is true for rental income. If your Fundrise portfolio holds a cash flowing portfolio, the rental payments are shared among the investors.
Finally, Fundrise aims to buy properties at a lower price and sell them at a higher price. This is called asset appreciation. All of these different methods allow you to make money with Fundrise.
Fundrise Fees & Returns
If you are curious about Fundrise returns, here’s how much I earned on my $5,000 Fundrise investment.
There is a flat annual fee of 1% on the Fundrise platform.
This is broken down as a 0.15% investment management fee to manage your portfolio.
The other fee is a 0.85% asset management fee to manage the underlying properties held in your portfolio.
Fundrise also has an asset origination/acquisition fee. This is a one time fee that can range from 0-2% of the initial investment. This is a fee for establishing real estate partnerships and the origination and negotiation of the underlying real estate assets.
Fundrise allows you to choose from four real estate portfolios based on your risk tolerance and investment goals.
Some portfolios aim for cash flow, and others focus on the growth of the underlying assets. If you invest the minimum of $500, you will have access to the starter portfolio. The other three advanced plans require a minimum investment of $1,000.
The Fundrise Starter Portfolio is for new investors who would like to give Fundrise a shot.
The minimum account requirement is only $500 needed by you to start investing.
This portfolio consists of 50 percent growth and 50 percent income-oriented holdings. If you want to upgrade to an advanced plan down the road, it is entirely free!
This Supplemental Income Portfolio holds income-producing real estate.
You can choose an option that will best meet your needs for supplemental income. This will create a consistent income stream by investing in cash-flowing real estate.
The goal here is to funnel quarterly dividends to you via a portfolio allocated mostly to debt real estate assets. Investors will earn returns primarily through dividends from cash flow producing real estate and interest payments. Dividends are generated through rental and interest payments in proportion to your share of the fund.
Around 25 percent of Fundrise investors choose this strategy, with the average age of investors in their 30s and the average investment is $6,670.
The Fundrise Balanced Investing Portfolio offers a blend of 50 percent growth and 50 percent income-oriented investments.
The goal for this portfolio is for a balance of the income-generating real estate, as well as real estate that is appreciating in value. Fundrise balanced investing helps you build wealth steadily through diversification.
If you buy into this class, the goal is to earn returns through a blend of dividends and appreciation. This is a balanced mix of income and growth strategies. The median age of investors in this class is 30s, and average investment is $6,800.
Current projects on the docket feature apartment renovations in Jacksonville, FL; new apartment development in Georgetown, TX; and new commercial projects in Colorado Springs, CO.
Long Term Growth
The fourth portfolio option is the Fundrise Long Term Growth Portfolio.
The goal of this portfolio is to generate returns primarily from property appreciation. This portfolio aims to buy high growth potential real estate and generate returns mostly from the sale of the underlying properties. This includes buying a property and performing renovations in order to sell the asset for a gain later.
This category will earn you returns on your investment via appreciation in share value, rather than consistent dividends. This is a growth-oriented strategy favored by people with an average investment of $7,600.
The wide array of projects currently includes apartment renovations in Charlotte, NC; new home construction in Daly City, CA; and new commercial development in Chicago, IL.
Fundrise uses the funds you invest to purchase real estate. For this reason, liquidity or the ability to sell is not guaranteed.
There is a 60-day waiting period for withdrawing funds. There are also quarterly redemption periods when you can withdraw your funds.
It’s vital to remember that a Fundrise investment is a long-term one, and you should expect to keep your money invested with them for at least 5 years. If you aren’t comfortable with this, you should consider a more liquid investment like a publicly traded REIT.
Investors who would like to redeem their shares before holding them for 5 years will pay an early redemption fee.
The fee is calculated as a discount to the share price of your investment.
- The redemption fee is 0% if in the first 90 days.
- A 3% discount if the shares were held at least 90 days but less than three years.
- A 2% discount if shares held at least three years but less than four years.
- A 1% discount if shares held at least four years but less than five years.
After holding the investment for 5 years, there is no early redemption fee.
Fundrise offers quarterly redemption periods, but liquidity is never guaranteed.
Real estate does not sell overnight, and if there are many people looking to pull out at the same time, they may not have the cash on hand.
You may also end up paying early withdrawal fees if you pull your money out early.
Fundrise eREIT & eFund
When you invest with Fundrise, you will get shares of eREITs and eFunds.
Keep in mind that Fundrise is a private real estate investment. You can only buy and sell Fundrise eREITs and eFunds on the Fundrise platform. They are not publicly traded on a stock exchange like a publicly-traded REIT.
Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) are corporations, trusts, or associations that invests directly in income-producing real estate and is traded like a stock.
An eREIT will produce income for your portfolio in the form of dividends.
Dividends are earned from the rent payments and interest payments from the underlying apartment and commercial leases owned within the eREIT as well as interest payments from debt investments.
An eFund is a partnership created by Fundrise to be treated differently for tax reasons and to provide greater investment flexibility.
Partnerships have the advantage of avoiding the double taxation of normal C-Corps. eFunds are designed by experts in a similar way to eREITs where there is a pool of real estate investments split into shares and sold to investors. Where eREITs are designed to generate income, eFunds were designed by experts for growth potential.
Getting Started With Fundrise
When you sign up, Fundrise will guide you through a series of simple but important questions to get a sense of who you are and where you stand financially.
The first step is to open an account here.
Next, you need to provide your age and whether you’re actively working or retired.
Next, you need to elaborate on your real estate experience. Maybe it’s home ownership, or apartment renting. Maybe it’s none.
Then, you will need to give some thought to your specific goals for signing up. Are you in it just to test the waters? Or have you pinned down an exact dollar goal in a spelled-out time frame?
Whatever your goal, chances are good you’ll find something to suit your goals and strategy.
Pros of Investing With Fundrise
- The minimum for investors to get started with the Starter Portfolio is $500.
- Small retail investors are able to access private real estate investments.
- Since this is a non-traded REIT, it may be less correlated with the overall market.
- Fundrise has a management fee of 1% per year.
- This investment allows you to earn compound interest, with the option of automatically reinvesting quarterly dividends using a drip (Dividend Reinvestment Plan).
- Fundrise does not have a minimum net worth or income requirement like most private investment funds do.
- This is a 100% passive real estate investment.
- Fundrise gives you diversified exposure to real estate.
- Fundrise supports retirement accounts.
- Quarterly redemption periods eliminate the temptation for panic selling.
Cons of Investing With Fundrise
- They cannot guarantee liquidity. During a downturn, liquidity may not be available as many investors will rush to sell, and buyers may be few and far between. Don’t rely on your real estate investment for handy cash.
- They cannot guarantee dividends, just like the stock market!
- Dividends will be taxed as ordinary income rather than capital gain rates.
- The platform has a limited track record as this is a brand-new investment.
Fundrise seems to be a great pick for the passive, hands-off real estate investor.
Unlike other crowdfunded real estate platforms out there, you do not have to be an accredited investor.
With a $500 minimum for the starter portfolio, this is a beginner-friendly investment. You can automatically reinvest your dividends, allowing you to put your money back into Fundrise earning you compound interest.
Realty Mogul Review
Realty Mogul has a sleek online platform that allows you to keep track of your real estate investment. This is a 100% passive, hands-off real estate investment where you invest in portfolios of real estate projects. Realty Mogul lets you buy into both commercial and residential properties.
Commercial sites include plazas, shopping centers, marketplaces and offices.
Residential projects include things like multi-family housing units such as condo or apartment complexes.
When you invest in real estate, you’re tapping into the potential for long-term appreciation, along with a regular, consistent cash flow.
How Does Realty Mogul Work?
Through the Realty Mogul platform, you will have the opportunity to put your money into real estate ventures through a user-friendly online platform. You can browse investments, review research that’s been done, and sign legal documents securely online.
Once invested, you will have access to an investor dashboard, giving you 24/7 access to watch your money grow and proliferate.
The platform has seen enormous success: to date, members of the public have invested over $400 million through Realty Mogul, financing more than 300 properties valued at over $2 billion.
Realty Mogul experts are constantly on the lookout for diversified, multi-tenant, centrally located, cash flow producing properties. Its investment team examines every project on the drawing board, checking it against hundreds of data priorities. This is one of the advantages of investing in a passive real estate investment, they do all the leg work for you!
Every Realty Mogul deal is put to the test against the most conservative financial models, and requires unanimous approval from an investment committee, whose members have collectively transacted more than $5 billion in real estate.
Getting Started With Realty Mogul
First, you create a Realty Mogul account.
Realty Mogul carries a minimum investment of $5,000.
Investment lengths start at just 6 months and range out to a high of 120 months. This lets you make your investment decisions specifically based on your own long and short-term goals.
To invest in Realty Mogul private placements, you must be an accredited investor. The minimum is also much higher, at $15,000 to $50,000. With private placements, you are investing in individual properties, not portfolios.
An accredited investor is someone who has a recognized level of income, net worth, or professional experience allowing them to invest in higher-risk securities that may not be registered by companies with traditional securities laws.
To be eligible to invest in Mogul REIT I and Mogul REIT II, you are not required to be an investor who is accredited.
You can invest in these REITs as long as you meet the $5,000 minimum investment.
In order to stay compliant with the SEC, the companies who issue unregistered securities must verify they are selling to accredited investors only. They may do this by verifying income and net worth of the investor.
When you create an account with Realty Mogul, you will need to answer some questions to expand on your goals for real estate investments.
Are you looking for returns in the shorter term to meet a specific need, such as a down payment, or do you plan to reinvest some of the dividends you’ve earned into new projects?
Investors can purchase equity investments in both commercial and residential real estate, as well as real estate debt investments. Realty Mogul offers multiple investment vehicles, however, some are only accessible to accredited investors.
Realty Mogul Investment Options
Both accredited and non-accredited investors can invest in the non-traded REITs. The private placements are for accredited investors only.
Mogul REIT I (Income)
One option is Mogul REIT I, a public, non-traded Real Estate Investment Trust (REIT) that gives you debt and equity investments in commercial real estate properties of different types and in various locations.
The REIT’s primary focus is providing monthly income and diversification to investors by taking a close look at numerous investment opportunities. The driving force of REITs is to allow investors to spread funds across multiple properties, creating higher levels of diversification.
The minimum investment for Mogul REIT I is $5,000. This investment is open to any type of investor, not just accredited investors.
Mogul REIT I has carried an average annualized return of 7.70 percent over its life.
Investors receive dividend payments every month.
Over time, REITs have provided investors of all types with regular income streams, diversification of their portfolio, and long-term capital appreciation opportunities.
There are currently more than 5,100 investors in this REIT, with 15 investments for a total of $272 million.
Mogul REIT II (Growth)
MogulREIT II is a public, non-traded REIT for residential real estate, primarily apartment building. It is set up for appreciation and income through investments in equity in multifamily apartment buildings with a minimum investment of $5,000.
Although RealtyMogul has paid a 4.5 percent annualized distribution to investors in MogulREIT II, the focus is also on long-term capital appreciation. This comes about from renovating, upgrading and repositioning the multi-family properties, which ups their net worth.
- Mogul REIT II looks for properties in established areas and neighborhoods. As a result, over the past year Mogul REIT II has paid out a 4.5 percent yield on distributions to investors.
- This REIT has the goal of paying out quarterly cash distributions to investors. The minimum investment for this REIT is $5,000. It is open to any investors and not limited to accredited investors.
Projects have included complexes in Texas, Brooklyn and Chicago. They are adding more all the time, so you may want to subscribe to their email list where they share new investment opportunities.
Realty Mogul also offers a variety of private placement investments. These private placements are for accredited investors only. For the most part, all private placement offerings are slightly different within Realty Mogul. Some may have investment minimums as well as lock-up periods for your initial investment.
There are currently more than 1,900 investors in this REIT, with 7 investments that have a combined value of $128,000,000.
Realty Mogul Fees
Realty Mogul charges fees based on the type of investment you select.
Typically you can expect to pay approximately a 1% annual asset management fee on Realty Mogul.
There are also REIT management fees that range from 0.50% to 0.60% annually.
Certain investments may also have legal fees for specific investment types. These fees are usually a one time fee for the initial origination of the investment.
Realty Mogul Pros
- Gives regular investors access to large scale real estate investments.
- Monthly or quarterly dividend distributions based on the investment.
- Investment options are clear and easier to understand than some similar platforms.
- Experts monitor projects on a consistent basis.
- You can manage and complete all documents for transactions online.
- User-friendly dashboard and experience with frequent project updates.
- Invest in both loans and equity investments.
Realty Mogul Cons
- Non traded REITs are not liquid in nature, so you need to have long term goals.
- Some investments are only for accredited investors.
- Fees vary based on the investment.
- Minimum of $5,000 initial investment is quite high.
Advantages of Crowdfunded Real Estate
Compared to buying and managing a rental property, real estate crowdfunding offers clear advantages, including:
- You will not need to handle any day-to-day responsibilities! Teams of experts manage the properties for you.
- You will know ahead of time what you’re getting into. They research each project thoroughly beforehand so that investors have as much info as possible to make wise decisions.
- You’ll receive tax benefits. Real estate crowdfunding allows investors to receive certain tax breaks, such as depreciation, that normally apply to owning an investment property.
Crowdfunded Real Estate Basics
Here are a few tips for making sure that your real estate crowdfunding venture turns out to be a wise choice, not a poor strategy on your part:
- Choose your platform carefully. Every real estate crowdfunding platform is different and some may be a better fit for your needs than others. Researching the various platforms to identify their strengths and weaknesses is an important first step for investors.
- Keep an eye on liquidity. Real estate has very different liquidity schedules as well as unique return profiles for each individual investment. It’s important to understand the length of time you need to set aside for a deal before you take the plunge into investment decisions. Real estate is not a highly liquid investment. Most crowdfunded real estate investments are a minimum 5-year commitment, with some debt investments being shorter. Remember, you may end up paying early redemption fees if you do not commit to the full investment term!
- Don’t overlook risk. Real estate is a good way to diversify your investment profile, but it also expands your risk as well. As with most avenues in the financial world, there are no absolute guarantees, so weigh the potential returns against the projected risk to decide what’s the best choice for your financial goals.
The Final Verdict
Fundrise and Realty Mogul are two of the most popular real estate crowdfunding investing platforms out there today. These platforms have a lot in common, but there are small differences between the two that you need to consider before making a choice.
Minimum Investment ($500 vs $5,000)
One important difference is the minimum investment. Investors can invest in the Fundrise Starter Portfolio with just $500. Realty Mogul has a $5,000 minimum investment for both MogulREIT I and MogulREIT II. This makes the barrier to entry for Fundrise much lower.
Dividend Payout (Monthly vs Quarterly)
Another major difference between Realty Mogul and Fundrise is the dividends payout structure. Realty Mogul has monthly or quarterly dividend payouts, while Fundrise has only quarterly dividend payouts. This may or may not play a big factor for you as an investor. But monthly payouts let you reinvest your dividends on a more frequent basis. Or, these monthly dividends can provide more consistent monthly income.
Fees (Straightforward vs Varied)
There is also a difference in fees between Fundrise and Realty Mogul.
Fundrise has a fee structure displayed directly on their website. The most common fees on Fundrise are the 1% asset management and portfolio management fee. However, Fundrise also has early redemption fees for liquidating your investment early as well as other commission-based fees.
Realty Mogul fees are more complex and dependent on the specific investment. In some cases, fees might be lower on Realty Mogul but higher in other cases.
Realty Mogul and Fundrise are offering a nearly identical investing platform. Investors pool money together via crowdfunding and invest in portfolios of commercial and residential real estate.
However you decide to invest, we recommend doing your homework and make sure you fully understand the investment you are making.